"Prangs for the Memories"
The Harry Clare Collection - Photos of Palestine and Syria, 1941.
"This Tommy is faulty Sarge, can
I have another one?"
This aircraft is a 250 Squadron Tomahawk
coded B. This aircraft crashed into AK414, shown below
- coded "S".
- The date of the accident was 7th May 1941. The accident
took place at Aqir just before the move to Lydda.
Introduction: RAAF No.3 Squadron's Campaign against the Vichy French in Syria
In May 1941, No.3 Squadron was withdrawn from action in the Western Desert of Egypt and transferred to Lydda in Palestine. (Now called Lod, Israel, located about 15km south-east of Tel Aviv.) This move was in preparation for the planned British-Commonwealth and Free-French invasion of Syria.
The Vichy-French Colony of "Syria" in those days incorporated both of the modern-day countries of Syria and Lebanon. Syria had been occupied by the French under a League of Nations Mandate, taking over from the defeated Ottoman Empire at the end of World War I. (The British had taken over Palestine under similar arrangements.) With the defeat of France by the Germans in mid-1940, the administration of Syria passed to the Vichy-French. The British observed that the Syrian Administration were collaborating with German attempts to fan Arab unrest in the Middle East and threaten oil supplies from Iraq. A British invasion of Syria was considered the best way to solve this problem!
No.3 Squadron was expected to provide about 40% of the available Allied fighter-force. They were issued with brand-new P-40 Tomahawks at Lydda in Palestine, to replace their battle-weary Hurricanes. However, the conversion to the new aircraft did not go smoothly at all. There were many "prangs" in training.
"Desert Warriors" author Russell Brown researched the causes of these accidents and put them down to a combination of:
1. A complete lack of technical manuals for the new aircraft type; resulting in mistakenly-high landing speeds at first.
2. Use of desert-style "wheelie landings" on the hard concrete runway. (Most of these pilots had not operated from concrete before.)
3. The fragile landing-gear in that early model of P-40C.
4. The inexperience of some newly-arrived replacement pilots.On June 3rd, 1941, Air Marshall Tedder, the RAF Commander-in-Chief in the Middle East, reported to London...
"The Australians are very unexpectedly making heavy weather over the Tomahawks, but I have applied a little ginger which, I hope, will have the necessary effect."
Ready or not, Tedder sent 3 Squadron into action on June 8th for the initial surprise attack on Syrian airfields. Fortunately, over the next five weeks of campaigning, the Squadron restored its reputation with a series of stunning victories that destroyed much of the French frontline airpower in Syria. No.3 Squadron accounted for more than two-thirds of the aerial victories in the campaign, with 24 aerial claims, 20 claims of French aircraft destroyed in ground-strafing, and 35 damaged. This establishment of Air Superiority greatly assisted the Allied ground forces to break through. In return, only three Tomahawks were shot down by the French - and all three Australian pilots avoided French captivity.
(However, a few more Tomahawks were "pranged" during the campaign, some after receiving battle damage.)
Meanwhile, the war on the ground had included a high proportion of Australian forces. For the second time in just over two decades, Australian troops fought their way along the "Road to Damascus". While this campaign ended in victory, Australian Army losses were serious, with over 400 killed, as the French valiantly defended their territory.
Harry Clare was a member of the 3 Squadron ground-crew during this campaign and he photographed some of the more spectacular Tomahawk bust-ups. Luckily, only a minor proportion of these accidents resulted in personnel injuries, although two fatalities sadly did occur. (One during training and another during the campaign.)
Harry's collection of tiny "contact prints" survived a fire that burnt down his tent (see below) - so we are lucky to still have them, to remind us of those days.
A few images from other sources have also been added...
The Harry Clare Collection
The "Australian Soldiers Club"
on the beach at Tel Aviv.
The view from the Australian
Soldiers' Club.
(A sabotaged Jewish refugee ship makes a nice breakwater!
The refugees were not welcomed by the British Mandate in
Palestine.
However they wisely scuttled their own ship so that they had to be
allowed to land.)
An early accident at
Lydda. On 26/5/41, Tomahawk AK365 (at
right), was parked near the runway.
It was hit
when Flying Officer
Davidson ran off the side of the runway while
delivering a brand-new Tomahawk (AK474,
at left) from Egypt.
Another view of the damage to
AK365.
Lydda had been a commercial airport
previously; in 1941 it was still being visited by KLM DC-3 airliners which serviced an
impressively long air-route all the way to the Netherlands East
Indies (modern-day Indonesia).
This particular aircraft (PK-ALW) went
on to have an amazing flying
career. When the Japanese attacked the NEI in 1942, PK-ALW
was evacuated to Australia, and operated for the rest of the war
with the RAAF,
including some flights transporting General Douglas
MacArthur. After the war it passed into airline service in
Australia and still survives in a
museum in Queensland today.
(For the full story see
http://www.qam.com.au/aircraft/dc-3/vh-anr.htm.
On one occasion, PK-ALW even flew under the Sydney Harbour Bridge
as part of a formation of Dutch planes! - See http://home.st.net.au/~dunn/shbdutch.htm )
A crashed
Tomahawk standing on its starboard
landing leg only; possibly AK410.
On 20/5/41 the port
undercarriage failed to lock down and collapsed on landing at Lydda
with Flight Lieutenant Blake Pelly
at the controls.
An aircraft of 250 Squadron RAF,
Tomahawk "J".
(In comparison, identification letters do not appear to have been
painted onto 3 Squadron Tomahawks at this stage in 1941.)
AK414
This scene of desolation
in an orange grove was the site of the
only fatal accident for 3 Squadron in
Palestine.
On 5/6/41,
Tomahawk AK408 spiralled into
the ground 2.5 miles east of
Jaffa, killing its
relatively inexperienced pilot, Sgt.
Norman Evans. Evans had been on a training
flight and it is suspected that may have blacked out during
aerobatics.
At the Squadron's advanced landing
ground at Rosh Pina in Northern Palestine, 3 Squadron personnel
were able to pitch their tents in a grove of eucalyptus trees,
which gave a very enjoyable home-like atmosphere. However,
the disconsolate men in this photo are Harry Clare's mates, viewing the ashes of their formerly-comfortable tent
after it had been accidentally burnt to the ground! Some of the photos in Harry's
collection are charred
from this fire.
A belly-landing. This
Tomahawk, AK 366 was hit by Vichy anti-aircraft fire on the 26th
of June 1941, while strafing road-transport, and later put down on
a stony plateau north of Lake Tiberius.
(Modern-day Sea of Galilee, Israel. The
Jordan Valley can be seen in the background of this
photo, which is looking west.) The Pilot, Sgt BAILLIE, was
unhurt.
1941-10. WESTERN DESERT. AN INFORMAL PORTRAIT OF FLYING
OFFICER FRANK FISCHER, DRESSED IN ARAB COSTUME,
WHO HAD TO MAKE A FORCED LANDING ABOUT
100 MILES BEHIND THE FRONT LINE ON THE LAST DAY OF THE
SYRIAN CAMPAIGN.
HE RETURNED TO ALLIED LINES WITH THE HELP OF ARABS. [AWM
010159]
Prisoners of War from the French
Foreign Legion.
Rayak Airbase, Lebanon. The
wreck of one of the dangerous Vichy-French Dewoitine D520
fighters, burnt-out on the ground.
Under new ownership. A 3
Squadron Tomahawk is visited by a refuelling truck at the former
Vichy-French airbase at Rayak.
A group of Vichy French pilots at
Rayak after the Allied occupation. The Armistice in Syria
freed all Vichy French military who agreed to transfer to the Free
French - these men probably came under those arrangements.
[Photo supplied by Peter Pritchard from the collection of his
Uncle L/Cpl. Paul Purtell, VX38118, Middle East GHQ, 6 Aust. Div.]
A lucky escape... After the
end of the Syrian campaign, 3 Squadron enjoyed a period of
relative peace based at
Rayak. However, there
was still the odd "prang". The aircraft on jacks in this picture is Tomahawk AM386,
named 'Sweet FA' and
usually
flown by Flight Lieutenant Al Rawlinson. (During the campaign, Flying
Officer Peter Turnbull
had used this aircraft to shoot down
two Dewoitine D520
fighters.) More than a month after hostilities had ceased,
on the 22nd of August, Al Rawlinson
had been practicing
aerobatics when he heard a
loud "crack" and saw to his horror that he had bent his vertical
tail-surface over at a right-angle. His starboard tailplane
had also been ripped off completely (as can be seen in this
photo).
Rawlinson found that the aircraft would became uncontrollable if he slowed down to the speed normally used for landing. Nonetheless he bravely decided to attempt a high-speed touchdown back at Rayak to save his aircraft. He succeeded in getting down safely, but just before he came to a halt he ran off the end of the runway and the Tomahawk tipped up on its nose into a ditch. (All of this damage proved repairable.)
Our photographer Harry Clare
serving in the Pacific Theatre later in the War, behind the
waist-gun of a B-24 Liberator.
[Editor's Note: Thanks to our reader "Buz" for correcting some of the captions above.]